Heavy quarks in the quark-gluon plasma experience rare, powerful momentum kicks that create asymmetric exponential tails beyond the familiar Gaussian pattern of Brownian motion

When two beams of gold ions collide at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider, they create the quark-gluon plasma. Shortly after the collision, the particles stream out to several detectors. This is the end view from STAR, one of four detectors. Credit: Brookhaven National Laboratory

As heavy quarks travel through the extremely hot matter created in high-energy particle collisions, most of their interactions resemble the small, random nudges of Brownian motion. But occasionally, they can receive much larger momentum kicks, producing an unusual pattern of energy and momentum exchange. A theoretical calculation now shows that these rare events are not simply random fluctuations around an otherwise Gaussian distribution. Instead, they create asymmetric exponential tails that play an essential role in how heavy quarks reach thermal equilibrium.

Heavy quarks are among the most useful probes of the quark-gluon plasma, an extraordinarily hot state of matter produced in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions. Unlike ordinary particles in the plasma, heavy quarks have relatively large masses and can survive long enough to interact repeatedly with their surroundings.

As they move through the medium, they exchange energy and momentum with its constituent particles. Following these exchanges allows physicists to investigate how strongly the plasma interacts and how it responds to particles moving through it.

For years, scientists have often described this process using Langevin dynamics, a mathematical framework closely related to Brownian motion. In this picture, a heavy quark experiences a combination of drag, which gradually slows it down, and random momentum fluctuations, which cause it to move unpredictably.

This approach is useful because it reduces complicated interactions with the surrounding plasma to a small number of transport properties, including the drag coefficient and momentum diffusion coefficients.

However, the description relies on an important assumption: that momentum transfers can be treated as approximately Gaussian, meaning their probability distribution follows the familiar bell-shaped pattern.

The new theoretical calculation challenges that assumption for heavy quarks moving at nonzero velocities through weakly coupled gauge-theory plasmas.

Jean F. Du Plessis of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Bruno Scheihing-Hitschfeld of the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics calculated the momentum-transfer distribution beyond the leading logarithmic approximation. They found that it has a Gaussian central region but develops asymmetric exponential tails at large momentum transfers.

The result is particularly interesting because a similar structure had previously been identified in calculations involving strongly coupled plasmas. Finding the same qualitative behavior in weakly coupled theories suggests that this feature is not restricted to one particular interaction strength or theoretical framework.

Why the Brownian-motion picture is incomplete

The traditional description of heavy-quark transport comes from an intuitive physical idea.

When a relatively massive particle moves through a much lighter thermal environment, it can experience many interactions that individually change its momentum by comparatively small amounts. Over time, the accumulated effects can resemble Brownian motion.

In a Gaussian Langevin description, the probability of receiving a particular momentum transfer is determined primarily by its average and variance. These correspond to the average momentum change and the strength of momentum fluctuations.

For heavy quarks, these properties are related to the drag coefficient and the longitudinal and transverse momentum diffusion coefficients.

The longitudinal coefficient describes fluctuations along the direction of the quark’s motion, while the transverse coefficient describes fluctuations perpendicular to that direction.

These quantities are especially important because they help connect theoretical calculations with observations of heavy-flavor particles produced in collisions.

However, a Gaussian description also imposes a specific relationship between drag and longitudinal momentum diffusion. This is known as the Einstein relation.

In a conventional Gaussian Langevin framework, satisfying this relationship is necessary for the system to reach thermal equilibrium.

The problem is that the Einstein relation is violated when a heavy quark moves through a weakly coupled plasma at nonzero velocity once corrections beyond leading logarithmic accuracy are included.

This creates a fundamental difficulty. If the Gaussian description cannot satisfy the required equilibrium condition, it cannot provide a complete microscopic account of the quark’s transport.

A similar problem had already been identified in strongly coupled theoretical plasmas. Earlier work also showed that retaining the complete statistics of momentum transfers leads to a more general description based on a Kolmogorov equation rather than a conventional Fokker-Planck equation.

That framework allows the full distribution of momentum changes, including higher-order fluctuations, to contribute to the equilibration process.

The central question for the new calculation was whether weakly coupled gauge theories also possess the non-Gaussian structure needed to resolve this problem.

Calculating momentum transfers across two physical scales

To investigate the problem, the researchers calculated how a relativistic heavy quark exchanges momentum with a weakly coupled thermal plasma.

Their theoretical treatment used the large-mass limit of heavy-quark effective theory, neglecting corrections proportional to inverse powers of the heavy-quark mass.

In this approximation, the heavy quark’s momentum-transfer probability can be expressed through a mathematical object called a Wilson loop. Its behavior encodes how the moving quark interacts with the surrounding gauge fields over time.

The calculation required particular care because weakly coupled thermal plasmas contain contributions from two distinct momentum scales.

The first comes from relatively hard momentum transfers, with characteristic momenta around the temperature of the medium, denoted by T.

The second comes from soft momentum transfers, with characteristic momenta around gT, where g is the gauge coupling.

Although the soft contributions involve smaller momentum transfers, they cannot simply be ignored. Their behavior requires a technique called hard-thermal-loop resummation, which accounts for important medium effects in the soft sector.

To obtain a consistent leading-order result, the researchers combined the perturbative hard contribution with the resummed soft contribution and subtracted the overlapping part. This prevents the same physical contribution from being counted twice.

However, this matching procedure introduces an additional technical problem.

The resummed soft contribution contains terms beyond the intended order of the perturbative calculation. Although these terms do not change the leading-order transport coefficients in the usual way, they become problematic when calculating higher-order momentum-transfer cumulants.

Cumulants describe different statistical properties of a distribution. The first is associated with the average momentum change, the second with its variance, and higher cumulants capture increasingly detailed features of the distribution’s shape.

For a Gaussian distribution, all cumulants above the second vanish.

But in the matched calculation, the higher cumulants become ultraviolet divergent if the unwanted higher-order contributions are not removed. This prevents a meaningful determination of the complete momentum-transfer distribution.

The researchers addressed this by separating hard and soft momentum regions using a cutoff at the thermal scale.

For momenta above T, they removed the soft resummed contribution and its matching term because their difference contributes only beyond the perturbative order being calculated. Below T, they retained the soft contribution but performed the radial momentum integration before expanding in the coupling.

This order of operations was important for correctly recovering the logarithmically enhanced terms.

The result was a strict fixed-order momentum-transfer kernel at order g⁴, free from the unwanted higher-order contamination.

The researchers also checked that changing the separation scale from T to another scale of the same order left the final kernel unchanged.

As an additional consistency check, they recovered the established heavy-quark diffusion coefficient in the zero-velocity limit.

These checks were important because the researchers needed a reliable description of the full momentum-transfer statistics, not merely an approximation that reproduced the familiar drag and diffusion coefficients.

The distribution has a Gaussian center and asymmetric tails

With the fixed-order kernel established, the researchers turned to the longitudinal momentum-transfer probability distribution.

They focused on the component of momentum transfer along the direction of the heavy quark’s motion. This is the relevant projection for examining the equilibration of an isotropic distribution.

To reconstruct the probability distribution, they used the cumulants of the momentum-transfer kernel and a mathematical procedure called a Legendre transform.

This approach retains information from all orders of the cumulants rather than stopping at the average and variance.

The resulting distribution has two distinct features.

Near its center, it is approximately Gaussian. This is the familiar bell-shaped behavior expected when many small, independent momentum transfers accumulate.

Farther from the center, however, the distribution departs from the Gaussian shape. Instead, it develops exponential tails that fall away at different rates on the two sides.

This asymmetry is an important part of the result.

A symmetric Gaussian distribution assigns equal probabilities to momentum transfers of equal magnitude in opposite directions. The calculated distribution does not follow that pattern. Its positive and negative tails have different exponential decay rates.

The difference is not an arbitrary feature of the mathematical calculation. It is connected to the generalized condition required for heavy-quark equilibration.

The researchers showed that their complete momentum-transfer kernel satisfies this condition, providing an important consistency check on the calculation.

The condition also determines the relationship between the two exponential tails. Once the decay rate on one side is known, the corresponding rate on the other side is fixed by the quark’s velocity and the temperature of the medium.

Faster heavy quarks develop stronger non-Gaussian behavior

The researchers examined how the shape of the distribution changes as the heavy quark’s velocity increases.

They compared results at three velocities: 0.10, 0.50 and 0.95, expressed as fractions of the speed of light.

To make the comparisons meaningful, they normalized the distribution using its first two longitudinal cumulants. This removes the overall drag and width, allowing the researchers to isolate differences in the underlying shape.

A purely Gaussian distribution would produce the same normalized parabolic curve regardless of these changes.

The calculated distributions did not consistently follow that benchmark.

At a velocity of 0.10, the weak-coupling result remained relatively close to the Gaussian curve across the plotted range.

At 0.50, the distribution was already visibly skewed, indicating a clear departure from Gaussian behavior.

At 0.95, the deviations became pronounced on both sides of the central region.

The comparison demonstrates that non-Gaussian features become increasingly apparent at higher velocities in the calculated distributions.

The researchers also compared different theoretical descriptions of the plasma.

These included weakly coupled N = 4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory at coupling values of 10⁻³, 10⁻² and 10⁻¹, as well as weakly coupled QCD with three massless quark flavors.

They compared these results with an existing strong-coupling calculation in N = 4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory.

Despite the differences between the theories and their interaction strengths, the normalized distributions displayed the same qualitative structure: a Gaussian central region accompanied by asymmetric exponential tails.

The weakly coupled N = 4 results showed relatively little variation across the range of coupling values considered. The weakly coupled QCD result also followed the same general pattern.

The strong-coupling calculation produced a similar asymmetric profile.

This comparison suggests that the structure is not peculiar to weak coupling, strong coupling, conformality or supersymmetry. The authors argue that it may be a robust feature of gauge-theory plasmas.

However, the comparison is between theoretical calculations. It does not constitute a direct experimental observation of the same distribution in the quark-gluon plasma produced in heavy-ion collisions.

Rare momentum transfers control the exponential tails

One of the most important parts of the calculation concerns the behavior of the higher-order cumulants.

These quantities determine how quickly the mathematical expansion describing the momentum-transfer distribution converges.

The researchers found that, in both weakly coupled gauge plasmas and the strongly coupled theory they considered, all the longitudinal cumulants are positive.

This produces singularities at the boundaries of the region where the corresponding mathematical expansion remains valid.

Those boundaries determine a quantity called the radius of convergence, denoted by R(v).

Physically, this quantity also determines the exponential decay rate of the positive large-momentum tail.

The negative tail has a different decay rate, fixed by the generalized equilibration condition.

In this way, the large-momentum behavior of the distribution is directly connected to the mathematical properties of the evolution kernel.

The researchers found that at zero velocity, the radius of convergence is 1/(2T).

In the ultrarelativistic limit, when the quark approaches the speed of light, the weak-coupling result becomes approximately 1/(4γ²T), where γ is the Lorentz factor associated with its motion.

For the strongly coupled N = 4 theory, the corresponding high-velocity behavior is approximately 1/(r₀γ²T), where r₀ is a numerical constant of about 1.7972.

These results show that the tail exponent contains information about both the temperature and the quark’s velocity, as well as the underlying dynamics of the medium.

Interestingly, the leading contribution to this quantity is independent of the coupling in both the weak- and strong-coupling calculations. Coupling dependence appears only at subleading order.

The researchers also investigated which physical processes generate the high-order cumulants responsible for the tails.

Their analysis indicates that these cumulants are determined by the hard contributions to the interaction, associated with momentum transfers around the thermal scale T, rather than by the soft physics described through hard-thermal-loop resummation.

This distinction helps explain why the exponential tails emerge even though the soft sector plays an essential role in determining the familiar diffusion properties.

The authors further argue that this dominance of hard contributions at large cumulant order should persist at higher orders in perturbation theory.

They also suggest that, in an asymptotically free gauge theory where the coupling changes with momentum transfer, the far tails should eventually be governed by the leading-order hard contribution calculated in their work.

Why the Gaussian center does not tell the whole story

At first glance, the presence of a Gaussian central region might suggest that conventional Brownian-motion descriptions remain adequate.

The researchers explain why that conclusion would be incomplete.

The central limit theorem states that the accumulation of many sufficiently independent random contributions tends toward a Gaussian distribution under appropriate conditions.

For a heavy quark evolving over sufficiently long times, the bulk of the momentum-transfer distribution therefore becomes increasingly well approximated by a Gaussian.

The exponential tails describe something different. They characterize relatively rare events in which the momentum transfer is much larger than the typical fluctuation.

As time increases, these events become increasingly suppressed relative to the central region. But their probability does not simply disappear.

More importantly, their asymmetry is essential for equilibration.

The Gaussian central region alone does not satisfy the Einstein relation at finite velocity. The complete distribution, including its higher-order cumulants and asymmetric tails, is needed to satisfy the generalized equilibration condition.

This means that the rare events contribute something that cannot be reproduced by simply adjusting the drag and diffusion coefficients of a Gaussian model.

There is also a practical reason why these events may matter even when their probability is small.

A realistic heavy quark has a large but finite mass and travels through the plasma for a finite amount of time. It therefore cannot fully reach the idealized asymptotic regime in which the central limit theorem completely describes the evolution.

An individual large momentum transfer can appreciably change the quark’s velocity. After such a change, its subsequent interactions occur at the new velocity, meaning they are governed by a different momentum-transfer distribution.

The original distribution no longer provides a complete description of its subsequent evolution.

Consequently, the authors argue that large momentum transfers can have significant dynamical effects beyond their role in ensuring thermal equilibration.

What the results mean for heavy-quark transport models

The findings have implications for how physicists describe heavy-flavor transport in the quark-gluon plasma.

Gaussian Langevin and Fokker-Planck approaches remain useful approximations, particularly when the central region of the momentum-transfer distribution is the main concern.

However, the calculation indicates that they are not automatically justified as complete microscopic descriptions of relativistic heavy-quark transport.

This distinction matters when physicists use theoretical models to interpret heavy-flavor measurements and extract transport coefficients from experimental data.

Previous Boltzmann transport studies have indicated that non-Gaussian momentum transfers can modify heavy-flavor observables and the transport coefficients inferred from them.

The authors connect this issue to a possible tension between phenomenological extractions and determinations of heavy-quark transport coefficients using lattice QCD.

Their results motivate revisiting these descriptions with non-Gaussian momentum-transfer kernels rather than relying exclusively on Gaussian approximations.

They suggest that a more complete description could be organized around three velocity-dependent quantities: the drag coefficient, the longitudinal momentum diffusion coefficient and the tail exponent.

The first two characterize the average momentum loss and the width of the central distribution. The additional parameter describes the slopes of the asymmetric exponential tails and therefore captures information about rare, large momentum transfers.

Whether this approach can consistently describe heavy-flavor observables as increasingly precise measurements become available remains an open question.

The authors identify future heavy-ion measurements, including those from the ALICE experiment’s Run 3 program and the proposed ALICE 3 detector upgrade, as opportunities to test the implications of more realistic transport descriptions. They also point to the complementary constraints expected from oxygen-oxygen and neon-neon collision data.

Their calculation establishes the non-Gaussian structure within the weak-coupling theoretical framework. Whether the same detailed behavior is realized in the physical quark-gluon plasma remains to be tested.

The study was published in Physical Review Letters.

Muhammad Tuhin

Founder & Science Writer

Muhammad Tuhin is the founder of TuhinNova and a research-based science writer passionate about exploring scientific knowledge and discoveries. His work draws on peer-reviewed research papers, scientific journals, and publications from reputable academic institutions. He focuses on transforming complex scientific research and findings into clear, engaging, and easy-to-understand content for a wider audience, with an emphasis on scientific accuracy, credible sources, evidence-based information, and responsible science communication.