The first few minutes of the universe were crucial for creating the ingredients that would eventually make up stars, planets and living things. During this brief period, nuclear reactions transformed some of the simplest particles into light elements such as hydrogen, helium, deuterium and lithium. Now, researchers have tested whether an alternative model of the universe, in which the cosmic expansion rate was three times slower during this early period, could still produce the same primordial elements. Their calculations suggest that it could, provided the reactions and radioactive decays responsible for element formation slow down in step with the expansion.
The result addresses an important question about a cosmological framework called covarying coupling constants plus tired light, or CCC+TL. Unlike the standard ΛCDM model, which describes the universe using dark matter and dark energy, CCC+TL proposes that certain fundamental physical constants change together over cosmic time.
The framework introduces a common scaling factor that affects quantities such as the speed of light, Newton’s gravitational constant, and Planck’s constant. However, dimensionless constants and ratios, which do not depend on physical units, remain unchanged.
The researchers wanted to determine whether these changes would disrupt Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN), the process that produced the universe’s earliest light elements.
Their calculations indicate that the alternative model can preserve the same light-element abundances predicted by standard cosmology. However, this agreement depends on an important assumption about how nuclear reaction rates and neutron decay rates change alongside the expansion rate.
The first elements depended on the universe’s cooling rate
Big Bang nucleosynthesis took place during the universe’s earliest minutes, when temperatures were high enough for nuclear reactions to occur.
At that time, the universe consisted primarily of protons, neutrons, electrons, neutrinos and photons. As it expanded and cooled, protons and neutrons began combining to form the nuclei of light elements.
One of the most important products was helium-4, which contains two protons and two neutrons. The process also produced deuterium, an isotope of hydrogen containing one proton and one neutron, along with smaller amounts of helium-3 and lithium-7.
The outcome depended on more than simply having the right particles available. The rate at which the universe expanded and cooled determined when nuclear reactions could begin and how much time they had to proceed.
A particularly important stage was the formation of deuterium.
Although protons and neutrons could combine to make deuterium, the early universe contained so many energetic photons that newly formed deuterium nuclei were quickly broken apart. The process could not proceed efficiently until the universe cooled enough for deuterium to survive.
This delay is known as the deuterium bottleneck. Once it ended, nuclear reactions could build helium and other light nuclei.
The survival of neutrons also mattered. Free neutrons are unstable and gradually decay, so the number remaining when nucleosynthesis began helped determine how much helium could form.
These processes make primordial element abundances sensitive to the relationship between the universe’s expansion, nuclear reaction rates and neutron lifetime.
In standard cosmology, the baryon-to-photon ratio, which compares the number of ordinary matter particles to photons, is another particularly important quantity. It strongly influences the amounts of deuterium and other light elements produced.
The researchers examined whether CCC+TL could preserve these relationships despite its different description of cosmic expansion.
What changes in the CCC+TL universe?
The CCC+TL framework proposes that physical quantities with an explicit length dimension change according to a universal scaling function, called f(z), where z represents cosmological redshift.
For example, the model assigns different powers of this function to different physical constants. The speed of light scales with the first power, while Newton’s gravitational constant scales with the third power. Planck’s constant and Boltzmann’s constant scale with the second power.
Dimensionless quantities, including the fine-structure constant, remain unchanged. The model also treats masses and electric charges as invariant.
An important feature of the framework is that its scaling function approaches a nearly constant value of approximately 3 at the extremely high redshifts associated with Big Bang nucleosynthesis.
This means the scaling does not continue changing rapidly throughout the nucleosynthesis period. Instead, the relevant physical quantities experience approximately fixed multiplicative changes.
The tired-light component also becomes negligible at these early times. In the model, tired light describes an additional contribution to the observed redshift associated with photons gradually losing energy as they travel through the proposed vacuum microstructure.
The researchers’ calculations indicate that this contribution has effectively disappeared by the time of Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Consequently, the early-universe test is governed primarily by the covarying-constant component of CCC+TL.
Despite these differences, the model retains the standard relationship between temperature and redshift. The temperature increases with redshift in the same way as in ΛCDM.
That feature allows the researchers to compare the two cosmologies at the same physical temperatures, including the temperatures associated with neutron-proton freeze-out and the deuterium bottleneck.
The expansion rate becomes three times slower
The central difference appears in the Hubble expansion rate, which describes how quickly the universe expands.
At a given temperature during the radiation-dominated early universe, the researchers calculate that the CCC+TL expansion rate is approximately one-third of the corresponding ΛCDM rate.
This follows from the high-redshift scaling function approaching a value of approximately 3.
A slower expansion rate means the universe takes longer to cool through a given temperature interval. According to the researchers’ calculations, the time required for the same temperature change becomes approximately three times longer.
Their figures illustrate this behavior. The ratio between the cosmic ages in CCC+TL and ΛCDM approaches approximately 3 at the redshifts relevant to nucleosynthesis.
However, a longer cooling time does not automatically mean that more helium or other elements will form.
The number of nuclear reactions that occur during a given period also depends on how quickly those reactions proceed. If the reactions slow down in the same proportion as the expansion, the additional time available may not change the overall outcome.
This relationship is the central part of the researchers’ proposed consistency test.
Nuclear reactions must slow down alongside expansion
One of the most important processes in early nucleosynthesis is the conversion of neutrons into protons and protons into neutrons through weak nuclear interactions.
These reactions help establish the neutron-to-proton balance before nuclear fusion becomes effective. That balance influences the amount of helium-4 that can eventually form.
The researchers examined how these interaction rates behave under the CCC+TL scaling rules.
They considered neutrinos, which are extremely light particles that interact through the weak nuclear force. In their scaling argument, the neutrino energy density changes with the scaling function, while the energy of individual neutrinos and their interaction cross-sections also change.
Combining these relationships, they obtain a weak interaction rate that scales inversely with the high-redshift scaling factor.
In other words, when the scaling factor reaches approximately 3, the relevant interaction rate becomes approximately one-third of its ΛCDM value.
The Hubble expansion rate decreases by the same factor.
As a result, the ratio between the neutron-proton conversion rate and the expansion rate remains unchanged.
This is important because weak interactions compete with cosmic expansion. When the universe expands and cools, these reactions eventually become too slow to maintain equilibrium. This point is called weak freeze-out.
If the reaction rate and expansion rate decrease together, their relative timing remains the same at a given temperature. The researchers therefore argue that the neutron-to-proton ratio at freeze-out can remain unchanged between the two cosmologies.
The same reasoning is extended to other interaction and decay rates that influence nucleosynthesis.
However, the authors do not establish this scaling independently for every relevant physical process. They introduce a broader rate-symmetry assumption under which interaction and decay rates inherit the same scaling as the Hubble expansion rate.
That assumption becomes particularly important when considering neutron survival.
Neutrons get more time, but their lifetime also increases
The time between weak freeze-out and the end of the deuterium bottleneck influences how many neutrons survive long enough to become part of heavier nuclei.
The researchers use a neutron lifetime of approximately 880 seconds in their discussion of the standard process.
If the CCC+TL universe takes three times longer to cool through the same temperature interval, neutrons would have more time to decay if their lifetime remained unchanged.
That would reduce the number of neutrons available for helium production.
But the authors propose that neutron decay rates also scale with the Hubble expansion rate. Under this assumption, a decay rate that becomes three times slower corresponds to a neutron lifetime that becomes three times longer.
The cooling interval and neutron lifetime therefore increase by the same factor.
Their ratio remains unchanged, preserving the fraction of neutrons expected to survive during the relevant period.
This is the second essential part of the argument. The model’s slower cosmic clock does not alter neutron survival if the decay process slows down proportionally.
The researchers acknowledge that deriving the exact scaling of the neutron lifetime from its underlying expression is not straightforward in CCC+TL. They therefore adopt the rate-symmetry assumption as an ansatz, or proposed scaling rule.
They also discuss an alternative relationship between cosmic microwave background temperature and redshift that has been proposed in a separate SU(2) Yang-Mills thermodynamic framework.
Under that alternative relationship, the temperature at a given redshift would differ from the standard one. The authors explain that their internal scaling argument would still hold at a fixed physical temperature and fixed baryon-to-photon ratio.
However, the mapping between present-day density measurements and the baryon-to-photon ratio during nucleosynthesis could change substantially. They estimate that the resulting shift in that ratio could be approximately a factor of 4.
Such a change would affect deuterium and lithium predictions and require a separate calculation. The possibility is outside the scope of their CCC+TL test, which retains the standard temperature-redshift relationship.
A modified nucleosynthesis code tests the prediction
To examine whether their scaling argument could reproduce standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis results numerically, the researchers modified the Kawano/NUC123 nucleosynthesis code.
This is an established computational tool for calculating the production of light elements in the early universe. The authors chose it because its relatively transparent structure made the necessary modifications easier to implement.
They explicitly state that their goal was not to achieve the high precision of more advanced codes such as AlterBBN. Instead, they wanted to test whether the proposed CCC+TL scaling changes could be implemented consistently and whether they preserved the predicted abundances.
The modifications were controlled by a single parameter, fctl, representing the maximum value of the scaling function.
They performed calculations using two settings.
The first used fctl = 1, representing the standard ΛCDM case. The second used fctl = 3, representing the CCC+TL early-universe scaling.
For the alternative cosmology, they adjusted the expansion rate, reaction rates, radioactive decay rates, neutron lifetime and computational time steps.
The expansion rate and relevant reaction and decay rates were reduced by a factor of 3, while the neutron lifetime and time steps were increased by the same factor.
Reverse nuclear reaction rates were calculated from the forward rates using detailed balance, so they inherited the corresponding scaling automatically.
The researchers then compared the resulting light-element abundances.
Their calculations produced virtually identical results for the two cosmologies. Differences appeared only at approximately the third or fourth significant figure, which the authors attribute most likely to numerical rounding.
One of the figures plots the abundances of different light elements as nucleosynthesis progresses with time.
It illustrates an important distinction between the models. The temperature scales are the same, but the CCC+TL clock runs three times more slowly. Consequently, the corresponding stages of nucleosynthesis take longer in cosmic time even though the calculated abundance histories remain essentially unchanged.
The result supports the mathematical consistency of the proposed scaling prescription within the modified code. It does not independently establish that every physical nuclear and decay rate in the actual CCC+TL universe must follow that prescription.
The baryon density introduces a separate difference
Although the researchers find that the scaling changes alone preserve the standard light-element abundances, CCC+TL also produces different estimates of the universe’s present-day critical and baryon densities.
This introduces another issue because Big Bang nucleosynthesis depends strongly on the baryon-to-photon ratio, not directly on the present-day baryon density parameter.
The researchers calculate the CCC+TL critical density using parameters obtained from two different observational fits.
One uses the Pantheon+ Type Ia supernova data. With a CCC expansion parameter of 59.5 kilometers per second per megaparsec, a scaling parameter equal to −0.80 times that value, and a total Hubble constant of 73.0 kilometers per second per megaparsec, they obtain a critical density approximately 2.7% of the corresponding ΛCDM critical density.
The second calculation uses parameters associated with the cosmic microwave background sound-horizon fit at recombination. With the same CCC expansion parameter, a scaling parameter equal to −0.75 times that value, and a total Hubble constant of 67.4 kilometers per second per megaparsec, the resulting critical density is approximately 4.8% of the ΛCDM value.
These estimates lead to a CCC+TL baryon-to-photon ratio ranging from approximately 56% to 100% of the ΛCDM value, under the model’s assumed conservation of baryon and photon numbers.
The photon energy density is taken to be the same in both cosmologies because the present-day cosmic microwave background temperature is the same.
The difference in the inferred baryon density therefore becomes important when the researchers compare the predicted light-element abundances across the range of possible values.
Lower baryon density improves lithium but increases deuterium
The researchers present these comparisons in a Schramm plot, which displays how the predicted abundances of different primordial elements change with the baryon density.
The figure includes helium-4, deuterium, helium-3 and lithium-7, alongside observational abundance ranges and the baryon-density regions associated with the different cosmological estimates.
The higher CCC+TL baryon-density estimate, obtained from the CMB sound-horizon fit, overlaps with the Planck value shown in the figure. At this higher density, the predicted light-element abundances are approximately the same as those in ΛCDM.
The lower estimate, associated with the Pantheon+ fit, produces a different result.
According to the authors, this lower baryon density reduces the predicted lithium-7-to-hydrogen abundance ratio by approximately a factor of 2.6 compared with the ΛCDM value.
This reduces the discrepancy between the standard BBN lithium prediction and the lower lithium abundances observed in metal-poor halo stars, a longstanding problem in primordial nucleosynthesis.
However, the same change increases the predicted deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio by approximately a factor of 2.
That creates a separate discrepancy involving deuterium.
The two effects therefore work in opposite directions. The lower baryon density improves agreement for lithium but worsens agreement for deuterium, while the higher density produces abundances similar to those predicted by standard cosmology.
The authors consequently conclude that Big Bang nucleosynthesis alone does not distinguish between the two CCC+TL baryon-density estimates considered in their calculations.
They emphasize that interpreting BBN constraints requires correctly translating present-day density estimates into the baryon-to-photon ratio relevant during the early universe.
The consistency result depends on the proposed rate scaling
The calculations provide a specific result: a CCC+TL cosmology with an early-universe scaling factor of approximately 3 can reproduce the same light-element abundances as ΛCDM when the expansion rate, relevant interaction rates and decay rates are scaled together.
But the qualification is essential.
The authors’ argument depends on the assumption that all relevant interaction and decay rates inherit the same scaling as the Hubble expansion rate. They describe this as a rate-symmetry ansatz and suggest that it may represent a prediction of the framework.
Their numerical test implements this assumption in the Kawano/NUC123 code rather than independently deriving the scaling of every nuclear reaction and decay process from the underlying physics.
The calculation also uses a relatively simple nucleosynthesis code with limited nuclear reaction data. Its purpose is to test the consistency of the proposed scaling, not to provide a high-precision reassessment of primordial element abundances.
The authors further distinguish the scaling test from the question of which late-time baryon-density estimate is preferable. Their results indicate that the lower estimate changes the lithium and deuterium predictions in opposite directions, while the higher estimate produces abundances similar to those in ΛCDM.
For the CCC+TL model, the central condition remains that the expansion history and the physical processes governing nucleosynthesis must scale together. Without that shared scaling, the longer cooling interval and altered neutron lifetime could change the balance of reactions that produces the universe’s first light elements.
The study was published in Universe.






