The quantum vacuum of the strong nuclear force may help explain why the universe is expanding faster, with its contribution to dark energy becoming significant only during the past few billion years

Credit: Tobias Roetsch/All About Space Magazine/Future)

The universe’s accelerated expansion may not be driven by a constant background of vacuum energy after all. Instead, a subtle quantum effect associated with the vacuum of the strong nuclear force could be changing as the universe expands, becoming increasingly important in recent cosmic history. A model built around this possibility reproduces the evolving dark energy behavior favored by recent observations from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) while remaining statistically competitive with the standard cosmological model.

The proposal connects two seemingly distant areas of physics: dark energy, the mysterious component associated with the accelerated expansion of the universe, and quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory describing the strong force that holds quarks together inside protons and neutrons.

According to the researchers, the quantum vacuum associated with QCD may respond to the large-scale geometry of spacetime. If that response changes as the universe expands, it could produce an effective dark energy component whose density evolves over cosmic time.

The idea offers a different explanation for cosmic acceleration. Rather than introducing a new fundamental particle or an extremely light field to drive the expansion, the model attributes the effect to the global quantum structure of the QCD vacuum.

In a detailed comparison with cosmological observations, the researchers found that this proposed mechanism can reproduce the late-time expansion behavior preferred by DESI data. It also performs particularly well when the statistical analysis accounts for the additional freedom introduced by the model.

The results do not establish that QCD vacuum effects are responsible for cosmic acceleration. They do, however, provide a detailed observational test of a physically motivated alternative to conventional descriptions of dark energy.

The problem with treating dark energy as constant

The standard cosmological model, known as Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM), describes the universe using six main free parameters. It successfully accounts for a wide range of observations, including measurements of the cosmic microwave background, the distribution of galaxies and the distances of astronomical objects.

In this model, cosmic acceleration is attributed to the cosmological constant, represented by Λ. It corresponds to a constant vacuum energy density and has an equation-of-state parameter of −1.

The equation of state describes the relationship between the pressure and energy density of a component of the universe. Its value helps determine how that component influences cosmic expansion.

A constant cosmological constant has the same equation-of-state value throughout cosmic history. But some recent cosmological observations have suggested that dark energy may behave differently.

One important development comes from the second data release of DESI, which measures baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) across a broad range of cosmic distances. BAO are patterns in the distribution of matter that provide a way to measure the expansion history of the universe.

DESI’s measurements cover redshifts from approximately 0.1 to 4.2. When combined with observations of Type Ia supernovae and the cosmic microwave background, the results have indicated a preference for models in which dark energy changes over time.

A commonly used description is the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder, or CPL, parametrization. It allows the dark energy equation of state to vary with the expansion of the universe through two parameters.

Such models can reproduce the evolving behavior suggested by observations. However, fitting the data better does not automatically mean that a more complicated model is preferred.

Adding parameters gives a model more freedom to accommodate observations. Statistical methods must therefore account for the possibility that an improved fit simply results from that additional flexibility.

This distinction has become particularly important in analyses of evolving dark energy. Some models improve the fit to observations but lose much of their advantage when Bayesian model selection penalizes unnecessary complexity.

The researchers wanted to investigate whether a different physical explanation could reproduce the observed evolution without relying on a conventional dynamical field.

Their candidate was dark energy emerging from the quantum vacuum of QCD.

A possible connection between the strong force and cosmic expansion

QCD describes the strong interaction, one of the fundamental forces of nature. It governs the behavior of quarks and gluons, the particles involved in the internal structure of protons and neutrons.

The QCD vacuum is not simply empty space. It has a complicated quantum structure, including different possible vacuum configurations associated with the topology of the underlying gauge fields.

These configurations are distinct in a mathematical sense. One cannot continuously transform one into another through ordinary changes in the field configuration.

Classically, the different configurations can have the same vacuum energy. Quantum mechanically, however, tunneling between them can mix the configurations and shift the energy of the true quantum vacuum.

The researchers explain this using an analogy with a quantum particle moving in a periodic potential. The particle can occupy different energy minima, and quantum tunneling between them changes the energy of its ground state.

The analogy has an important qualification. In QCD, the different minima do not represent separate locations in ordinary space. They represent different vacuum configurations.

The proposed tunneling is therefore not the creation of bubbles that expand into surrounding regions. Instead, it contributes to a single quantum vacuum state with effects that can extend across the universe.

The central idea behind QCD-induced dark energy is that this vacuum contribution may depend on the global geometry of spacetime.

An expanding universe and flat Minkowski spacetime, the familiar idealized setting of special relativity, have different large-scale geometries. If the QCD vacuum responds differently to these geometries, their vacuum energy densities need not be identical.

The researchers describe dark energy as the difference between the QCD vacuum energy density in an expanding universe and its value in Minkowski spacetime.

This difference is proposed to generate an additional contribution to the energy density of the universe.

The mechanism is unusual because it does not depend on a new propagating particle or field. Instead, it arises from the global topological structure of the quantum vacuum.

Why the effect could depend on the expansion rate

A central feature of the theoretical proposal is that the vacuum energy correction is proportional to the Hubble parameter, which measures how rapidly the universe is expanding.

The predicted correction is therefore connected to both the characteristic energy scale of QCD and the expansion rate of the universe.

This relationship is important because QCD operates at an energy scale of roughly 170 million electron volts, conventionally written as ΛQCD ≈ 170 MeV.

At first glance, connecting a nuclear physics scale to the expansion of the entire universe might seem counterintuitive. QCD is associated with microscopic distances, while cosmic expansion operates over enormous scales.

The researchers argue that the connection is possible because the relevant contribution to the QCD vacuum is topological and nonlocal.

In particular, they discuss a nondispersive contribution associated with the topological susceptibility of the vacuum. Unlike ordinary contributions controlled by propagating particles, this component is not restricted to microscopic distances by the QCD mass gap.

Consequently, the authors argue that it can remain sensitive to large-scale properties of spacetime.

The theoretical motivation includes calculations involving QCD vacuum configurations in different geometries. One important result is a correction that depends linearly on a characteristic inverse length scale rather than quadratically, as might be expected from a conventional local treatment.

The authors also discuss calculations in a weakly coupled version of QCD, where the vacuum energy can be examined in a finite spatial box. In that setting, the correction scales linearly with the inverse size of the box.

They further point to lattice calculations involving a de Sitter background, which provide support for a linear dependence on the Hubble parameter through a related particle-production calculation.

These arguments motivate the proposed connection, but they do not amount to a direct measurement of the QCD vacuum contribution in the expanding universe.

The extension from these theoretical results to the cosmological setting remains an important part of the underlying proposal.

Why the effect becomes important only recently

The model faces a basic cosmological requirement.

Dark energy must remain sufficiently suppressed during the early universe. Otherwise, it would interfere with the established evolution during the radiation-dominated and matter-dominated periods.

However, the proposed QCD contribution becomes relevant at late times, when the universe enters its accelerated expansion phase.

To describe this behavior, the researchers begin with a relationship in which the dark energy density is proportional to the time-dependent Hubble parameter.

But they recognize that simply applying this relationship throughout cosmic history would not correctly reproduce the expected early-universe behavior.

The theoretical framework therefore introduces an additional condition called the adiabatic approximation.

In simple terms, the approximation requires the expansion rate to change sufficiently slowly for the proposed vacuum contribution to respond in the assumed way.

This condition is strongly violated during the early universe. It becomes increasingly accurate as the universe evolves toward its present accelerated expansion.

The researchers use this behavior to motivate an additional suppression of the QCD-induced contribution at high redshifts.

They implement that suppression through a function called β(z), which acts as a switch controlling when the dark energy contribution becomes important.

At very high redshifts, β approaches zero, suppressing the QCD-induced component. As the universe evolves, the function increases, allowing the contribution to become more significant. In the asymptotic de Sitter limit, corresponding to the distant future of accelerated expansion, β approaches one.

The transition is described using two parameters.

The first, zq, determines the approximate redshift at which the switch becomes important. The second, Δzq, controls the width of the transition.

This function is a phenomenological implementation of the expected suppression. The researchers emphasize that they cannot currently calculate the full correction exactly for an arbitrary expansion history.

That distinction is important. The underlying proposal provides the physical motivation, while the switch function supplies a practical way to implement its expected time dependence in cosmological calculations.

The resulting QCD-DE model has eight cosmological parameters, including the six parameters of the standard ΛCDM framework and the two additional transition parameters.

It behaves like ΛCDM during the early universe but develops a different expansion history as the QCD-induced contribution becomes important.

Testing the model against observations of the universe

To determine whether the proposed framework can describe the observed universe, the researchers implemented its cosmological equations in a modified version of the Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System, a computational framework used to calculate cosmological predictions.

They compared QCD-DE against two alternatives: ΛCDM and w₀wₐCDM, the latter being the conventional two-parameter CPL description of evolving dark energy.

The analysis combined three major categories of cosmological observations.

The first was the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the radiation left over from the early universe. The researchers combined temperature and polarization measurements from the Planck satellite, the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the South Pole Telescope’s SPT-3G instrument.

They also incorporated CMB gravitational-lensing measurements, which provide information about how matter is distributed along the paths traveled by the microwave background radiation.

The second category consisted of DESI DR2 baryon acoustic oscillation measurements, covering redshifts from approximately 0.1 to 4.2.

The third consisted of Type Ia supernova observations. These included the Pantheon+ catalog and the Dark Energy Survey’s Year 5 sample, which had been reanalyzed using the updated Dovekie calibration.

The researchers tested several combinations of these datasets, including CMB measurements alone, supernova and BAO measurements together, and combinations incorporating all three observational categories.

They used Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling to explore the allowed cosmological parameters and estimate how well each model could reproduce the observations.

The analysis also included several statistical methods to distinguish between a genuinely better description of the data and an improvement obtained simply by adding more parameters.

These included the Akaike information criterion (AIC), the deviance information criterion (DIC) and Bayesian evidence.

Bayesian evidence is particularly useful because it evaluates how well a model explains the data while accounting for the range of parameter values the model allows.

A more complicated model must provide enough improvement to compensate for the additional parameter space it introduces.

The researchers also used a learned harmonic mean estimator, supported by normalizing flows, to estimate Bayesian evidence from their Markov Chain Monte Carlo results.

This allowed them to examine the competing cosmological models using several complementary statistical approaches rather than relying on the best-fitting parameter values alone.

The preferred transition occurs around redshift 0.68

One of the most important results concerns when the QCD-induced dark energy contribution becomes significant.

Using the combined CMB, DESI and updated DES supernova dataset, the researchers obtained a preferred transition redshift of approximately 0.68.

The reported constraint was:

zq = 0.68, with a 68% confidence interval extending approximately from 0.37 to 0.99.

The Pantheon+ combination produced a closely consistent result, with a central value of approximately 0.66.

The width of the transition was also constrained. For the updated DES supernova combination, the researchers obtained Δzq ≈ 0.82, with an uncertainty of approximately 0.18.

These results indicate that the observations favor a gradual activation of the QCD-induced dark energy contribution during relatively recent cosmic history.

The CMB-only analysis provided much weaker information about the transition redshift. It constrained zq only from above, giving a 68% confidence-level upper limit of 1.77.

Adding the late-time distance measurements from DESI and supernovae substantially improved the constraint.

This difference is understandable within the model. The CMB primarily provides information about the early universe and the distance to the surface from which the background radiation was emitted. DESI and supernova measurements offer more direct information about the expansion history at later times.

The results therefore show that the preferred timing of the proposed transition is particularly sensitive to observations of the late universe.

The researchers also examined the cosmological parameters inferred by the competing models.

For the full CMB-SPA+DD+DESI combination, the QCD-DE model produced a present-day Hubble constant of 67.74 ± 0.52 kilometers per second per megaparsec.

The corresponding ΛCDM value was 68.14 ± 0.24.

The QCD-DE model also produced a matter density parameter of 0.3109 ± 0.0049, compared with 0.3049 ± 0.0033 for ΛCDM.

The shift in these parameters is associated with the additional freedom in the late-time expansion history. The researchers explain that the cosmic microwave background tightly constrains the physical matter density, creating a relationship between the inferred matter density and the present-day expansion rate.

The additional dark energy parameters allow the model to accommodate a different expansion history while preserving the distance to the last-scattering surface favored by CMB observations.

The inferred parameters were also consistent when the researchers substituted Pantheon+ for the recalibrated DES supernova sample.

This stability is particularly relevant because the statistical performance of conventional evolving dark energy models can depend more strongly on the supernova compilation being used.

Dark energy crosses the phantom divide earlier in the QCD model

Another distinctive result concerns the effective equation of state of dark energy.

Although QCD-DE does not contain a conventional dynamical dark energy field, the researchers can calculate an effective equation-of-state parameter to compare its behavior with other cosmological models.

The resulting evolution has three distinct stages.

In the past, the effective equation of state was below −1, a behavior commonly described as phantom-like.

At an intermediate redshift, it crosses the boundary at −1.

Today, it is above −1, giving it a quintessence-like effective behavior.

As the universe approaches the asymptotic de Sitter state, the effective equation of state tends toward −1.

The most interesting feature is the timing of the crossing.

For the QCD-DE model, the preferred crossing occurs at approximately redshift 0.67, with reported uncertainties of +0.15 and −0.12.

The corresponding CPL model favors a crossing around redshift 0.35, with uncertainties of +0.08 and −0.07.

This places the QCD-DE crossing substantially earlier in cosmic history.

The difference is noteworthy because the authors point out that other dynamical dark energy parametrizations have generally produced phantom-crossing redshifts around 0.3–0.4.

The QCD-DE model therefore predicts a different pattern of effective dark energy evolution.

The authors associate this behavior with the physical origin of the proposed mechanism. In conventional scalar-field descriptions, evolving dark energy is connected to the dynamics of an additional field. In QCD-DE, the evolution instead arises from the changing contribution of the vacuum energy correction as the universe expands.

There is also an important theoretical distinction.

Phantom behavior can introduce stability problems in conventional models involving propagating scalar fields. The QCD-DE framework does not introduce such a field or its associated propagating degrees of freedom.

The authors therefore argue that the effective crossing does not produce the same conventional instability problem.

However, the equation of state here is a derived description of the model’s background expansion. It should not be interpreted as evidence that a physical substance with a conventional phantom equation of state exists.

Bayesian evidence gives QCD-DE an advantage when datasets are combined

The statistical comparison is arguably the most important part of the observational analysis.

The QCD-DE model does not simply achieve a better fit under every observational combination. Its strongest advantage appears when early- and late-time measurements are considered together.

The researchers compared the models using three information and fit statistics, alongside Bayesian evidence.

For the Bayesian comparison, they calculated the logarithm of the Bayes factor relative to ΛCDM.

A positive value indicates a preference for the alternative model, while a negative value favors ΛCDM.

The results reveal an important difference between QCD-DE and conventional evolving dark energy.

For the CMB-only dataset, QCD-DE has a log Bayes factor of −0.72. This indicates a preference for ΛCDM.

For Pantheon+ combined with DESI, the QCD-DE result is approximately 0.00, making it statistically indistinguishable from ΛCDM under this comparison.

For the updated DES-Dovekie supernova sample combined with DESI, the value becomes +0.28, still indicating no substantial preference.

The picture changes when the early- and late-time datasets are combined.

With CMB-SPA, Pantheon+ and DESI, the QCD-DE model obtains a log Bayes factor of +1.72.

With CMB-SPA, DES-Dovekie and DESI, the value increases to +2.02.

The authors describe the latter result as moderate Bayesian evidence in favor of QCD-DE.

The corresponding value for the conventional w₀wₐCDM model is only +1.02.

This difference is important because both dynamical dark energy models contain two additional parameters relative to ΛCDM.

The conventional model can improve the best fit to the observations, but its additional flexibility is penalized more strongly in the Bayesian comparison.

For the CMB-SPA+DD+DESI combination, the QCD-DE model has a difference in the Akaike information criterion of −5.15 and a difference in the deviance information criterion of −10.42.

Negative values favor the alternative model in both comparisons.

The corresponding values for w₀wₐCDM are −7.50 and −11.63, respectively.

Although the conventional model performs slightly better under these two particular criteria, QCD-DE retains a stronger Bayesian preference.

The best-fitting likelihoods also improve relative to ΛCDM. For the same dataset combination, the difference in χ² is −11.21 for QCD-DE and −12.85 for w₀wₐCDM.

These numbers illustrate why the researchers used several statistical methods. The conventional model achieves a slightly better best fit, but the QCD-DE framework performs more favorably under Bayesian evidence.

The distinction becomes even clearer when the two supernova compilations are compared.

The QCD-DE results remain relatively stable when Pantheon+ is replaced by the recalibrated DES-Dovekie sample.

Its Bayesian evidence changes from approximately zero to +0.28 for the late-time combination, and from +1.72 to +2.02 for the full combination.

The conventional w₀wₐCDM model exhibits substantially larger changes, including a shift from a log Bayes factor of −2.86 to −1.72 for the late-time combinations.

The authors regard this stability as an encouraging feature of the QCD-DE framework.

Importantly, the Bayesian evidence does not favor QCD-DE in every dataset combination. Its advantage emerges primarily when the observations covering different periods of cosmic history are considered together.

The cosmic microwave background provides another way to distinguish the models

The researchers also investigated how the different dark energy descriptions affect the temperature and polarization patterns of the cosmic microwave background.

These patterns are represented by angular power spectra, which describe how fluctuations in the background radiation vary across different angular scales.

They examined both temperature anisotropies, called TT, and E-mode polarization, called EE.

For the CMB dataset alone, the three models produce broadly similar predictions across most of the measured multipole range.

The largest differences occur at low multipoles, which correspond to the largest angular scales in the microwave background.

At these scales, late-time effects on the expansion history can influence the temperature anisotropies through the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect.

In the TT spectrum, QCD-DE produces a stronger suppression of power at the lowest multipoles than either ΛCDM or the conventional w₀wₐCDM model.

The researchers note that this behavior allows the QCD-DE model to reproduce the observed low quadrupole more closely.

The polarization spectrum provides another distinction.

For CMB-only data, QCD-DE and w₀wₐCDM produce different low-multipole EE behavior. Both models show suppression relative to ΛCDM, but the suppression is considerably less pronounced for QCD-DE.

When late-time measurements from DESI and supernovae are included, the preferred solutions change.

The temperature spectra retain an important difference between QCD-DE and w₀wₐCDM. In particular, the best-fitting QCD-DE model develops an excess of power at low multipoles relative to ΛCDM, while showing a slight suppression across the damping-tail region.

The EE spectra also change. Both dynamical dark energy models now show substantial suppression of power at low multipoles compared with ΛCDM.

The researchers emphasize that the polarization behavior becomes more similar between the two models after the late-time datasets are included.

These differences demonstrate that the predictions of the models depend on the combination of observations used to constrain them.

The CMB spectra therefore provide an additional diagnostic of how the proposed dark energy evolution affects the universe’s expansion history.

DESI distances reveal a different pattern of cosmic expansion

The researchers also examined baryon acoustic oscillation distance measurements to understand the physical differences between the two evolving dark energy models.

DESI measures three related distance indicators.

The transverse distance describes distances across the line of sight, while the radial distance describes distances along it. A third quantity combines the two into an isotropic distance measure.

These measurements are expressed relative to the sound horizon at the baryon drag epoch, a characteristic length scale associated with the early universe.

The resulting distance residuals reveal how each model departs from the standard ΛCDM expansion history.

One important result is that QCD-DE produces a more moderate change in the transverse distance than w₀wₐCDM while still passing through the DESI measurements.

The radial distance shows a more distinctive difference.

Both evolving dark energy models produce an oscillatory pattern relative to ΛCDM. Their predicted distances are smaller than the standard model at low redshifts and larger at higher redshifts.

However, the redshift at which the transition occurs is different.

For w₀wₐCDM, the crossing occurs below redshift 1.

For QCD-DE, it shifts to redshifts above 1.

The overall amplitude of the oscillation remains comparable between the models. The principal difference is therefore the redshift dependence of the modification rather than simply its size.

A similar pattern appears in the combined distance measure.

The conventional w₀wₐCDM model predicts a minimum around redshift 0.4, while QCD-DE shifts the minimum to approximately 0.7.

This shift occurs close to the redshift region where DESI has particularly strong sensitivity to the expansion history.

The researchers interpret these patterns as evidence that QCD-DE reproduces the evolving distance-redshift relationship through a different physical prescription from the conventional CPL parametrization.

The two models can produce broadly comparable fits while retaining distinguishable predictions for the expansion history.

What the model does and does not establish

The proposed connection between QCD and dark energy offers a different way to approach several longstanding problems associated with the cosmological constant.

One of these is the coincidence problem, which concerns why the energy densities of matter and dark energy are of comparable importance during the present cosmic epoch.

Another is the enormous separation between the observed dark energy scale and the characteristic energy scales of particle physics.

The QCD-DE framework attempts to connect the dark energy scale to the QCD scale rather than introducing an entirely new fundamental scale or an additional ultra-light scalar field.

Its proposed mechanism also provides a reason for dark energy to become important only during late cosmic history. The contribution is suppressed when the early universe does not satisfy the required adiabatic condition and becomes increasingly relevant as the universe approaches accelerated expansion.

However, the observational analysis does not directly measure the topological structure of the QCD vacuum or demonstrate that it generates dark energy.

What it establishes is that a cosmological model built around this proposal can reproduce a range of current observations and perform competitively under several statistical comparisons.

There are also important qualifications within the theoretical implementation itself.

The exact time-dependent suppression of the QCD contribution cannot currently be calculated for an arbitrary expansion history. The researchers therefore use the β(z) switch function as an effective phenomenological description.

They also acknowledge that other possible forms of this switch function could be explored. The present analysis uses one particular parametrization with two additional parameters.

The study focuses on the background evolution of the universe rather than a complete description of new propagating dark energy perturbations. This follows directly from the model’s proposed nonlocal, vacuum-based nature.

The authors identify improved measurements of the late-time expansion history as an important way to test whether the observational preference for evolving dark energy persists.

They also point to the possibility of developing more fundamental descriptions of the time-dependent suppression instead of relying on its current phenomenological implementation.

For now, the strongest result is the model’s statistical performance when early- and late-time cosmological observations are considered together. The QCD-DE framework remains competitive with ΛCDM across the tested datasets and receives moderate Bayesian support in the most constraining full combination.

Whether the proposed quantum vacuum mechanism actually accounts for the universe’s accelerated expansion remains an open question.

The study was published in The Astrophysical Journal.

Muhammad Tuhin

Founder & Science Writer

Muhammad Tuhin is the founder of TuhinNova and a research-based science writer passionate about exploring scientific knowledge and discoveries. His work draws on peer-reviewed research papers, scientific journals, and publications from reputable academic institutions. He focuses on transforming complex scientific research and findings into clear, engaging, and easy-to-understand content for a wider audience, with an emphasis on scientific accuracy, credible sources, evidence-based information, and responsible science communication.